8
The Committee received and considered the report from the Housing Services Group Manager which detailed the procedures for tenants and residents to review or appeal housing decisions. The Housing Services Group Manager reported that a consistent approach was adopted to enable timely and appropriate decisions and this process had the advantage of being flexible and reasonably quick to administer. This allowed applicants to be informed of revised decision as soon as possible so that they may consider all options available to them.
The Housing Services Group Manager reported that decisions made on housing matters were subject to the right of judicial review which would remain as an option should a person wish to continue the appeal process.
A Member was concerned that the Housing Appeals Committee had not been included in the new Committee structure and was unaware that this decision had been made. Councillor Robinson-Payne felt that the proposed scheme would lead to an officer reviewing another officer decision, which in the eyes of the appellant, could be seen as non-transparent decision making and she felt that the public would prefer to have their appeal considered by Members.
The Housing Services Group Manager reported that Members could still support residents in the appeal process and that the need for the Housing Appeals Committee could be considered at the Governance Committee review in six months time.
Councillor Williamson reported that he agreed with Councillor Robinson-Payne as tenants were often vulnerable or had complex housing needs and needed help and support which Members could offer through the review process. Councillor Williamson proposed an amendment to the recommendation that the Housing Appeals Committee be reinstated after six months if required.
RESOLVED:
(i) That the procedure for reviews and appeals detailed in paragraph 2.4 of the Group Manager Housing Services's report be adopted for housing decisions;
(ii) That the Housing Appeals Committee will be reinstated after 6 months, if required.